Obama denies being an ideologue or a
Bolshevik, why? Is he ashamed of his heritage and convictions, just intent on
keeping his motivations covert until the right time to spring his true nature
upon us, or is there a technicality that we need to grasp?
Perhaps
we should analyze the term Bolshevik. Historically, the Bolsheviks were a
faction of the Marxist Russian Social Democratic Labour Party (RSDLP), founded
by Vladimir Lenin. They split from the Menshevik faction in 1903, during the
Second Party Congress. They eventually gained control during the October phase
of the Revolution in 1917. Bolshevik means "majority" or "large" and the
nickname resulted from having the majority rule in a crucial vote. Later on
after gaining complete control, Lenin maintained that since there was no
opposition, there was no longer the need to call themselves the majority party
or Bolsheviks, thus they named themselves the Communist Party of the Soviet
Union.
Eventually,
Lenin died and Stalin gained control of the party. Trotsky was exiled and wrote
extensively condemning Stalin’s "incorrect" version of Communism by referring to
it as Bolshevism, a derivative of Bolshevik, in apposition to Leninism.
Consequently the term Bolshevik developed negative connotations for the "pure"
Communist; perhaps this explains Obama’s displeasure at being called a
Bolshevik. He like many others must feel the sting of those who are critical of
Stalin’s regime.
The
term, Ideologue, evolved in the highly contested political and philosophical
debates of the French Revolution; coined by Destutt de Tracy, initially, it
referred to the study of the science of ideas or the study of ideas and the
means and logic of those ideas.
Later,
Napoleon used the term as a pejorative toward his political opponents, since
that time it has been used as a term of derision in political discussion to
point out an opposing politician’s inability to grasp ideas that are different
than those of his party line, thus reflecting a pettiness and lack of cognitive
ability.
Obama's
taking exception to being considered an Ideologue becomes a matter of conjecture
when examining the platform of America’s Communist Party. Although Obama denies
any association with the Communist Party of the United States, (CPUSA) they are
in express agreement with all of his policies. They could not have had a better
representative if they had won the election.
The
CPUSA’s stated goals are to achieve a free,
prosperous, and peaceful society free of racism, sexism, homophobia, and
exploitation, in which all people have the opportunity to develop to their full
potential. These same goals were espoused by Obama during his campaign, the
same goals of the Social Democrats and of the Progressive Democrats. The
Communists above all maintain that they advocate a peaceful Socialist Revolution
and a peaceful transition to Socialism. Obviously if they didn’t, the Communist
Party would be outlawed; therefore the claim is probably one of expediency and
is purely academic.
All
things considered, I understand why a true Marxist in the Russian tradition
balks at being labeled a Bolshevik. It is an insult from the days of Trotsky’s
bitter writing over his ouster and banishment. Being upset at being labeled an
Ideologue is a matter of history. In the context of the early days of the
French Revolution, Obama should consider it a compliment to be called an
ideologue. If his frame of reference is from the Napoleonic perspective, he is
indeed an Ideologue, after all Karl Marx frequently implied that it was
essential to be an Ideologue. Obviously Obama is confused over these issues as
he seems to be over many issues. It would probably be a much easier if he would
just be honest with the American People and admit that he is a Communist
Ideologue, with his reelection chances diminishing daily, he has reached the
point where honesty can only improve his ratings. Of course if he had been
honest in the beginning, he would have never been elected.
There
can be little argument that the agendas of Obama, the Democrat Party, and the
CPUSA are strikingly similar -- cursor down on the Flopping Aces link to review
a condensed version of the CPUSA platform.