New reasons emerge almost daily as to why
Obamacare can and must be defeated.
The American people oppose Obamacare by
almost 2 to 1 in the latest CNN poll. Other polls show lopsided opposition to
passing either the Senate or House
health-care bill. Public opinion is against the bill because of its obscene
costs in higher taxes, burdensome debt, anti-freedom mandates, rationing, and
reduced care for seniors. The American people have awakened to the fact that
Obamacare is transformational legislation that will drag us against popular will
into European-style Socialism.
The Democrats’ double-counting of
Obamacare’s financial benefits has been exposed as a colossal lie. Harry Reid
told the Senate that his bill strengthens our future by both “cutting our
towering national deficit by as much as $1.3 trillion over the next 20 years”
AND “strengthening Medicare and extending its life by nearly a decade.” The
Congressional Budget Office (CBO) refuted that assertion. CBO said the claim
that Obamacare would provide these benefits simultaneously “would essentially
double-count a large share of those savings and thus overstate the improvement
in the government’s fiscal position.”
Obamacare is unconstitutional because of
its mandate that all individuals must carry “approved” health
insurance, and all businesses must give health insurance to their employees
whether or not the company can afford it. “Universal” coverage will be enforced
by the Internal Revenue Service with power to punish those who don’t have such a
plan. Constitutional lawyers point out that the Commerce Clause does not give
Congress the authority to force Americans to buy health insurance as a condition
of living in our country because personal health insurance is not “commerce.”
The CBO wrote that “a mandate requiring all individuals to purchase health
insurance would be an unprecedented form of federal action”; the Supreme Court
has never upheld any requirement that an individual must participate in economic
activity.
Since the Senate bill imposes sharp
limits on health-insurance companies’ ability to raise fees or exclude coverage,
it likely will force many of them out of business. Obamacare is unconstitutional
because it violates the Bill of Rights protections against takings without just
compensation and deprivation of property without due process of
law.
Other Obamacare provisions blatantly
legislate racial and other forms of discrimination. The U.S. Commission on Civil
Rights sent two letters to the President and congressional leaders warning about
the obnoxious requirements for racist and sexist quotas. The Senate bill
requires that “priority” for federal grants be given to institutions offering
“preferential” admissions to minorities (race, national origin, sex, sexual
orientation, and religion). Institutions training social workers, psychologists,
psychiatrists, behavioral pediatricians, psychiatric nurses, and counselors will
be ineligible for federal grants unless they enroll “individuals and groups from
different racial, ethnic, cultural, geographic, religious, linguistic, and class
backgrounds, and different genders and sexual
orientations.”
Obama’s claim that “everybody” will now
be covered creates few winners but lots of losers. Universal health insurance will be achieved by forcing young people to pay the additional
costs (insurance for the youngest third of the population would rise by 35
percent), and by restricting and rationing care for the
elderly.
According to Robert Samuelson in the
Washington Post, the “wild card is immigration.” From 1999 to 2008, 60 percent
of the increase in the uninsured occurred among Hispanics, and Obama’s refusal
to close our borders will make this problem more costly every
year.
Obamacare gives Medicare bureaucrats the
power to ration health care by forcing doctors to prescribe cheaper medical
devices and drugs. In the recent case of Hays v. Sebelius, the court ruled that
Medicare doesn’t have the right to make this rule, but Obamacare takes
jurisdiction away from the courts to hear any appeal from decisions of the new
Medicare Commission. The “stick” applied to primary-care doctors is imposing
financial penalties if they refer too many patients to specialists. The “carrot”
is financial rewards to doctors who give up small practices and consolidate into
larger medical groups or become salaried employees of hospitals or other large
institutions.
The Senate bill contains at least a dozen
of what can be described as bribes. Senator Mary Landrieu received a $300
million increase in Medicaid funding
for her state (known as the Second Louisiana Purchase), and Senator Ben Nelson
received $100 million permanent exemption for Nebraska from the costs of
Medicaid expansion.
The Senate bill even has a four-page
section artfully written to enable ACORN to get federal health-care grants. This
section describes grant recipients as “community and consumer-focused nonprofit
groups” having “existing relationships ... with uninsured and underinsured
consumers.”